Home › Guides › Why retro games are expensive

COLLECTING GUIDE · RETRO GAMES · 2026

Why Are Retro Games So Expensive?

Short answer: Retro games are expensive because no one makes the original cartridges anymore, so a fixed and shrinking supply meets a growing crowd of collectors and grown-up fans who now have money to spend. A collecting boom in 2020 and 2021 pushed prices up fast. Not every old game is pricey, though: on November 5, 2026, loose Super Mario Bros. 3 carts were listed on eBay for about $18–$25, while EarthBound, a game that sold far fewer copies, was listed for about $430–$560. Will prices go down? Nobody can promise that. The top end of the market did drop after 2021, but scarce, well-loved games have stayed expensive.

By the RetroSnag team · Published November 5, 2026

The main reasons, in plain English

  • No new copies are being made. Original cartridges went out of production decades ago. Every copy that exists today is all there will ever be, and the number goes down every time one breaks or gets lost.
  • Most boxes and manuals were thrown away. Kids opened games to play them. Cardboard boxes got crushed or recycled, so a complete copy in nice shape is much harder to find than the cartridge alone.
  • The kids who played them grew up. People who loved these games growing up now have jobs and spending money, and many want back the games they had, or the ones they couldn't afford back then.
  • Some games sold very few copies. Games that sold modestly, or came out late in a console's life, were made in small numbers. When one of those becomes a cult favorite, prices jump.
  • The 2020–2021 boom. Lots of people were home with time and money, and headline auction records drew in new collectors and investors.
  • Fakes make genuine copies worth more. Popular, pricey games are reproduced often. Buyers will pay extra for a copy they trust is real.

Not every retro game is expensive

"Retro games are expensive" really means "some retro games are expensive." Games that sold millions of copies are still easy to find and cheap. Here's what sellers were asking on eBay on November 5, 2026, from our daily price check pages:

Game (loose cart, US)Typical asking priceListings sampled
Super Mario Bros. 3 (NES)$18–$25138
Super Mario 64 (N64)$40–$5599
Paper Mario (N64)$80–$10062
Pokémon Emerald (GBA)$200–$24041
Chrono Trigger (SNES)$270–$42021
EarthBound (SNES)$430–$56027

Prices are current eBay asking prices, not sold prices: the middle half (25th to 75th percentile) of fixed-price US listings for loose, US-region cartridges, before shipping, captured from the eBay Browse API on November 5, 2026. Asking prices move daily and are usually higher than what copies actually sell for. Click a game for today's numbers.

Super Mario 64 is a good example. It was the best-selling Nintendo 64 game, so loose copies were listed for about $40–$55, even though a sealed, graded copy once set an auction record. EarthBound sold far fewer copies and gained a cult following, and it costs ten times as much loose.

What happened in 2020 and 2021

Retro game prices had been rising slowly for years, but they took off during the pandemic. People had time, money and a lot of nostalgia, and sealed games graded by companies like Wata started selling for big money at auction. In July 2021, Heritage Auctions sold a sealed Super Mario 64 for a world record, two days after a sealed Legend of Zelda had set the record.

Those headlines pulled in new collectors and investors, and prices rose across the hobby, from rare grails to everyday games. Some collectors questioned whether the auction market was being hyped, and a 2022 class-action lawsuit made those claims. The companies involved denied wrongdoing, and no fraud was proven.

Will retro game prices go down?

Nobody knows for sure, and we won't pretend to. Here's what's actually happened so far:

  • The top end already fell. Sales of sealed, graded games at auction dropped sharply in 2022, and the big headline sales stopped.
  • Everyday games stayed cheap. Games that sold millions of copies were never scarce, so they're still affordable loose.
  • Scarce favorites stayed expensive. Games with small print runs and lots of fans, like EarthBound and Chrono Trigger, are still pricey, because the supply can't grow.

Prices for any single game can move up or down with new fans, re-releases, or a popular video. If you're buying to play, buy when you find a fair price rather than waiting for a crash that may never come. If you're buying as an investment, be careful: nothing guarantees a game will be worth more later.

How to pay less for retro games

  1. Buy loose if you just want to play. A box and manual can double the price or more.
  2. Compare the all-in price. A cheap listing with high shipping isn't a deal. Add the two together.
  3. Know the usual range. Check our price check pages or eBay's sold listings before you buy.
  4. Be wary of deals that look too good. A pricey game listed far below the usual range is often a reproduction. Our reproduction cartridge guide shows what to look for.
  5. Be patient. Fair-priced copies of most games do show up. An alert that watches for them saves you from refreshing eBay every day.
  6. Consider other ways to play. Nintendo Switch Online includes NES, Super NES and Game Boy games, and the Expansion Pack adds Nintendo 64 and Game Boy Advance games.

FAQ

Why are retro games so expensive?

Because the supply is fixed and demand keeps growing. Original cartridges stopped being made decades ago, many were lost, broken or thrown out, and boxes and manuals were usually tossed. Meanwhile, people who grew up with these games are now adults with money to spend, and a collecting boom in 2020 and 2021 brought in lots of new buyers. Games that sold fewer copies, like EarthBound and Chrono Trigger, feel this the most.

Will retro game prices go down?

Nobody can say for sure, and anyone who promises it is guessing. What we do know: after a big run-up in 2020 and 2021, prices at the very top, for sealed and graded games at auction, fell sharply in 2022. Everyday games that sold millions of copies are still cheap. Scarce, well-loved games have mostly stayed expensive, because there just aren't many copies to go around.

Why did retro game prices go up so much in 2020 and 2021?

People were stuck at home with time and money, nostalgia was high, and record-breaking auction sales made headlines. In July 2021, a sealed, graded copy of Super Mario 64 set a world auction record at Heritage Auctions, two days after a sealed Legend of Zelda had set the record. That attention pulled in collectors and investors, and prices rose across the hobby.

Are retro game prices crashing?

Not across the board. The high end, sealed and graded copies sold at auction, did drop a lot after 2021. Loose cartridges of common games have stayed cheap, and rare, popular games are still expensive. Check the specific game you want rather than trusting a headline about the whole market.

Why is EarthBound so expensive?

EarthBound sold far fewer copies in North America than Nintendo's biggest hits, and it later became a cult favorite, so lots of people want a small number of carts. On November 5, 2026, loose US copies on eBay were listed for about $430–$560. It's also one of the most reproduced SNES games, so check carefully before you buy.

Why are old Pokémon games so expensive?

The main Game Boy and Game Boy Advance Pokémon games are loved by a huge number of people who grew up with them, and the GBA ones, like Emerald, are also among the most faked carts. Strong demand plus worry about fakes keeps prices for genuine copies high.

Is it cheaper to play retro games another way?

Yes. Nintendo Switch Online includes a library of NES, Super NES and Game Boy games, and the Expansion Pack adds Nintendo 64 and Game Boy Advance games. Many classics, like Chrono Trigger, have also been re-released on modern systems. Buying the original cartridge mostly makes sense if you want to collect it or play on original hardware.

How can I pay less for retro games?

Buy loose carts when you just want to play, be patient, compare the full price including shipping, and avoid anything far below the usual price, since that is often a reproduction. A free price alert, like RetroSnag's, can watch eBay for you and email you when a listing hits your price.

Let RetroSnag watch for you

Waiting for a fair price on a pricey game? Tell us what you want and the most you'd pay including shipping. We check eBay every few hours and email you only the listings at or under that price, with reproductions and the wrong condition or region filtered out. It's free for up to 3 wishlist items.

Set my EarthBound alert ▶

Thank you for signing up! It truly means a lot, and it actually helps support our little family.
You rock!

Keep reading

Facts checked on November 5, 2026 against Heritage Auctions' July 2021 press release, Rally's 2023 video game market report, and reporting from Kotaku and Time Extension.